VK 96/97 Review Report Form

VK 96/97           REVIEW REPORT


Paper Number: VK7

Programme Committee Member: Eva R Fåhræus

Date: 97-03-03

Note: Please return this form to programme chairman at
          e-mail:


Which are the topics the paper addresses? Presentation, 

modelling, and analysis techniques that ease the process of 

restructuring existing information systems.


Confidential comments for committee use only (mandatory):
----------------------------------------------------------

Originality:                8            1-10

Significance of topic:      10            1-10

Technical Quality:          10            1-10

Relevance to VK 96/97:                  1-10

Presentation:               10             1-10

Overall Rating:             9            1-10

Reject: 0-3  Weak Reject: 4-5  Weak Accept: 6-7   Accept: 8-10

9

Referee's expertise on the topic:        Low  Medium  High: medium

Amount of rewriting required:            Low  Medium  High


Comments to Authors    (mandatory fill-in by referee):

Main contribution(s): Encourage business tool and I-CASE tool producers 

to develop truly integrated tools, by formulating requirements.

Positive aspect(s): By describing a real case requirements are formulated 

and existing tools evaluated.

Negative aspect(s): ?



Further comments (optional if desired):


--------------   cut here  for e-form review form ----------